Mayer's 40th birthday gift to Aniston disappoints Aniston
John Mayer surprised his girlfriend Jennifer Aniston with a song for her 40th birthday. Jennifer was so moved by the gift that she was brought to tears. She sobbed to friends, "I wanted something thoughtful, original, from the heart….like the iPod touch." Friends of Aniston were seething with anger. Longtime Aniston pal Courtney Cox-Arquette-Cox was heard viciously hissing at Mayer, "This is exactly why girls don't like sensitive guys, because they make girls cry." Cox-Arquette-Cox later taunted a brooding Mayer, "Dare I ask what were you going to get Jen for Valentine's Day? Ewww, a poem?" Even Aniston nemesis Angelina Jolie was reportedly blown away by Mayer's out of control thoughtfulness, "Mayer really crossed the chivalrous line. Brad (as in Pitt) never would have hurt Jen like that. Honestly, a song? Don't be cheap AND pathetic."

